April 23, 2026
Dear Editor,
The current race for District 5 Supervisor includes two men who have been the District 5
Supervisor before and one man who has not, Bruce Giudici. The two prior supervisors failed to
address many local problems during their time in office. Here are a few examples.
District 5 residents continue to deal with the congested Highway 12/26 intersection in Valley
Springs. The County has planned a bypass for that intersection since 1975. Over fifty years later
there is still no bypass. In the meantime, bypasses and truck routes have been completed for
both the City of Angels and San Andreas.
Flooding on Cosgrove Creek damaged many homes in 2006, and a subsequent report idenƟfied
tasks the County should do to address the flooding. However, no flood control district was
formed, no flood control project was completed, flood control maintenance on Cosgrove Creek
was repeatedly deferred, and homes were damaged again by another flood in 2023.
Timely economic development in District 5 is often delayed by the need to address impacts to
federally designated threatened and endangered species. In 2006, the County began a
countywide Habitat Conservation Plan (HCP) process to streamline project approvals but the
project was abandoned. In 2019, the county’s General Plan again promised to complete an HCP,
but, despite the availability of state funding, the County has still done nothing.
This year, the County missed its January 1, 2026, deadline to update its Open Space Plan, which
places new permit and project approvals on resource production land in legal jeopardy not only
in District 5 but throughout the county.
We do not need a Supervisor who is good at complaining about problems and coming up with
excuses for his inaction. We need a Supervisor who can envision realistic solutions, allocate
necessary resources, organize people to take action, and complete important tasks on time. You
know, govern. For the sake of all of us who live in Calaveras County, I hope the District 5 voters
figure out which candidate that is.
Sincerely,
Muriel Zeller, District 5 Resident
Valley Springs
This letter appeared in the Valley Springs New and the Calaveras Enterprise