project focused on sustainable land use planning.
Find out more about us >>
Testimony, Comments & Opinions
September 2024
San Andreas Fairfield Marriot Hotel Proposal
- Muriel Zeller Comments to PC on Fairfield Hotel Proposal
- CPC Comments to PC, BOS on Fairfield Inn proposal
- MVS.com Comments
Short Term Vacation Rental Ordinance (STVRO)
June 2024
CPC memo to agencies with public lands in Calaveras re: ZOU & Map Update
CPC Comments on the Zoning Code Update
Attachment 1: Special Events Instructions
Attachment 2: Special Events Application
Attachment 3: Nevada County Special Events Application
Attachment 4: Placer County Special Events Application
Attachment 5: Safe Outdoor Event Production
May 2024
CPC Member Muriel Zeller’s Comments on Conservation Easements and the Zoning Code Update
April 2024
CPC Comments on Flint Trail Road extension
MVS.Com Comments on the EOT for CV-Saddle Creek
CPC Member Muriel Zeller’s Comments on the Zoning Code Update 4/8/24
Attachment: Rural Clustered Development
MyValleySprings.com Comments for PC Review of Telecommunications Facilities in Draft Zoning Code
CPC Comments on the Zoning Ordinance Update April 2, 2024
Housing & Community Development Housing Accountability Technical Assistance Advisory
March 2024
CPC Comments on Group Homes in the TPZ
- CPC Letter to County
- Group Home Technical Advisory 2022
- Amador County Code
- Calaveras Evacuation Needs and Emergency Preparation Plan
February 2024
CPC Member Muriel Zeller’s comments on the draft Oak Woodland Ordinance
- Comments submitted February 28th
- Carbon Farming : CA Association of Resource Conservation Districts
- LAFCO Comments 1.24
- Mitigation: CA Council of Land Trusts
- Tuolumne County Oak Ordinance
January 2024
CPC Member Muriel Zeller’s comments on the draft Oak Woodland Ordinance
- November 6 2023 to BOS
- January 10 2024 to Hardwood Advisory Committee
- January 29, 2024 to the Planning Commission
CPC Member Muriel Zeller’s comments to RCD and LAFCO re:Open Space, Oaks and Carbon sequestration
2024 GPU Implementation letter to Director
November 2023
CPC Member Muriel Zeller’s Comments on GHG Reduction Plan
October 2023
Funding is available for the HCP/NCCP needed for development
- Attachment 1 – Draft-HCP-Phase-One-Proposal
- Attachment 2 – Draft-HCP-Planning-Agreement
- Attachment 3 – White, Project Status Update 2-18-10
- Attachment 4 – Willis, Staff Report for Sawmill Lake Project, 12-7-12
- Attachment 5 – Northern Sierra Connectivity Project Report, pp. 1-34
- Attachment-6-Californias-Fourth-Climate-Change-Assessment-Sierra-Nevada-Region-pp.-27-53.pdf
- Attachment 7 – Mokewise_Public_Interest_Profile_Enhancement_Project_
- Attachment 8 – Local Input to NSNFCP_Map_Report_final
- Attachment 9 – Map of Habitat Blocks and Corridors 2013
CPC Member Muriel Zeller Comments on ZOU and Open Space
20231010 CPC Letter to PC re ZOU District Rules Final
Attachment 1 – General Plan Update Code Amendment Checklist October 9 2023
Attachment 2 – State and Federal Zoning Code Requirements
September 2023
CPC Member Muriel Zeller’s Comments on Draft Oak Woodlands Ordinance
Supplemental information on In Lieu Fees
August 2023
CPC Member Muriel Zeller’s Comments on the Calaveras County Draft Oak Woodlands Ordinance
CPC Member Muriel Zeller’s Comments on Draft Copperopolis Community Plan
Attachment 1: Copperopolis Appraisal Report
CPC Support for MVS.com Comments on Copperopolis Community Plan
MyValleySprings.com Comments on Draft Copperopolis Community Plan
Attachment 1: Copperopolis Planning Area Map_OC-CV Ranches not within boundary
Attachment 2: BOS Ariola Agenda Submittal 23 GPA_Dec 4_Snapshot-19475
Attachment 3: Copper Valley Ranch Parcel Map appr_PC_080306m
Attachment 4: DEED 2020-000515-1 CA Rangeland Trust_Airola
Attachment 5: PC Resolution 2018-060 Oak Canyon Ranch_Attachment-7013
CPC Comments on Calaveras Evacuation and Access Needs Assessment and Preparedness Plan
CPC Comments on GHG Reduction Plan
Copperopolis Community Plan Comments
June 2023
CPC Member Ralph Copeland Comments on Copperopolis Community Plan
CPC Member Janet Sterling Comments on Copperopolis Community Plan
CPC Member Muriel Zeller Comments on Copperopolis Community Plan
CPC Comments on Copperopolis Community Plan
March 2023
MVS.com comments on Flint Trail MND
Attachments:
- Flint Trail Access Road MND Figure 2 Project Site Map_Pg. 16
- FlintTrail Access Road location_CCWD-Tuscany Hills Parcels
- item-7c-cv-holdings-subdivision-2_09_14_20
- Page 51 Map_CCWD 3-10-2021-Agenda-Package_surplus parcel-road to Tuscany Hills
- Tuscany Hills Phase I Final Map Sept 2019_BOS 03_10_20 Attachment-9472
January 2023
2023 GPU Implementation letter to Director
December 2022
Thoughts on Rural Clustered Development
November 2022
Letter to Planning Commission re:GHG Reduction Measures
Letter to County re: Conservation Education in Greenhouse Gas Reduction Plan
October 2022
Email to Director Elliot re:General Plan
CPC Comments on Economic Development
CPC Comments on Oak Woodland Ordinance
May 2022
CPC Facilitator Comments on Greenhouse Gas Inventory and Reduction Plan
Attachment 1 – Attachment 2 – Attachment 3 – Attachment 4
CPC Member Comments on Greenhouse Gas Inventory and Reduction Plan
April 2022
CPC Facilitator Comments on Greenhouse Gas Inventory and Reduction Plan
CPC Member Comments on Greenhouse Gas Inventory and Reduction Plan
February 2022
CPC Comments on General Plan Update Implementation Priorities
November 2021
CPC Comments on Draft Climate Adaptation Strategy
September 2021
August 2021
Project Consistency with Valley Springs Community Plan – MyValleySprings.com
June 2021
It is time to try something new when it comes to implementing plans in Calaveras County
May 2021
Empty Promises – a 13 year General Plan Process
Green House Gas Implementation in Calaveras County
April 2021
CCWD Must Be Transparent in the Sale of this Acreage
February 2021
Diverse Communities Deserve Their Own Plans
January 2021
- General Plan Implementation Work Program and Priorities
- Attachment 1 -List of Project Specific Evaluations
- Attachment 2 – GPU Implementation Plan from Sacramento
- Attachment 3 – GPU Implementation Plan from Amador County
- Attachment 4 – GPU Needs Implementation Staff
- Attachment 5 – CPC Press Release re GPU implementation hearing of 1-21-2.
- Attachment 6 – Flexible plan for 2019 General Plan Implementation
- Attachment 7 – Funding Programs for Implementing the General Plan Update.
- CPC Comments on the Proposed Zoning Map
- Open Space Zoning – Letter to BOS
July 2020
April 2020
- Letter of Support for Garamendi Conservation Easement
- Letter to BOS – Setting Priorities for Implementation of the General Plan
Related Documents for Reference
RESOURCE PRODUCTION LAND CONVERSION GUIDELINES
RESOURCE PRODUCTION LANDS MITIGATION PROGRAM GUIDELINES
CALIFORNIA SUSTAINABLE AGRICULTURAL LANDS CONSERVATION PROGRAM GUIDELINES FOR GRANT APPLICATION
Ecosystem Categories and Rangeland – UCANR
December 2019
- Notice to Agencies: Press Copy press copy notice to agencies
- Notice to Attorney General of Petition Filed Notice to AG
- Petition for Writ of Mandate https://calaverascap.com/12-8-19-petition-for-gpu-writ-of-mandate/
- Final Memos Sent to BoS November 2019 https://calaverascap.com/final-memos-sent-to-board-of-supervisors/
November 2019
- Opinion: The Valley Springs Community Plan Redux https://calaverascap.com/opinion-the-valley-springs-community-plan-redux/
- Opinion: The General Plan Update Is Over, Hypothetically https://calaverascap.com/opinion-the-general-plan-update-is-over-hypothetically/
August 2019
- Letter to the Editor: Valley Springs Deserves Better https://calaverascap.com/letter-to-the-editor-valley-springs-deserves-better/
- Letter to the Editor: Elected representatives’ job is to represent wishes of constituents https://calaverascap.com/letter-to-the-editor-elected-representatives-job-is-to-represent-wishes-of-constituents/
- Valley Springs News : Lack of Responsiveness in General Plan Update Hearings https://calaverascap.com/valley-springs-news-lack-of-responsiveness-at-general-plan-update-hearings/
July 2019
- Video: CPC members speak up at GPU Hearing to defend Community Plans https://calaverascap.com/videocpc-members-speak-up-at-gpu-hearing-to-defend-community-plans/
- Board of Supervisors Completes General Plan Update Hearing: Prepares to Rescind Community Plans https://calaverascap.com/board-of-supervisors-completes-general-plan-update-hearing-prepares-to-rescind-community-plans/
- Public Record Request for the Mintier-Harnish General Plan draft https://calaverascap.com/public-record-request-for-the-mintier-harnish-general-plan-draft/
June 2019
- Video : Why Retain Our Community Plans https://calaverascap.com/keep-our-community-plans-video-from-june-22-2019/
- Calaveras Enterprise : Planning Commission Approves General Plan Update, Eliminates Community Plans https://calaverascap.com/planning-commission-approves-general-plan-update-eliminates-community-plans/
- Spring/Summer 2019: Important Planning Commission Hearing Documents https://calaverascap.com/important-planning-commission-hearing-documents/
April 2019
- BREAKING! Coalition urges Supervisors to include Community Plans in General Plan Update https://calaverascap.com/breaking-coalition-urges-supervisors-to-include-community-plans-in-general-plan-update/
- General Plan Final EIR Released https://calaverascap.com/general-plan-final-eir-released/
- 2019 General Plan Comprehensive Guide https://calaverascap.com/2019-general-plan-comprehensive-guide/
January 2019
- Video: CPC urges County to adopt a legally defensible General Plan https://calaverascap.com/video-cpc-urges-county-to-adopt-a-legally-defensible-general-plan/
- Memo delivered to Board of Supervisors on GPU and DEIR fixes https://calaverascap.com/memo-delivered-to-board-of-supervisors-on-gpu-and-deir-fixes-on-january-22/
August 2018
July 2018
- Calaveras Enterprise “My Turn” : PG&E seeks agreement for the new safety program PG&E My Turn in CE
June 2018
- Email to Planning Commission re: Saddle Creek Development Agreement Extension To_PC_by_email_on_Saddle_Creek_DA_fin
March 2018
- Comments on Mokelumne River Draft Wild and Scenic River Study Report Final letter on Moke to Wall 3-1-18
October 2017
- Eleventh Hour consideration of Medical Cannabis Cultivation and Commerce Ordinance Project. A review and opinion letter of a report submitted to Board of Supervisors by County Supervisor Dennis Mills. By CAP’s Muriel Zeller –
- The Draft 2017 RTP provisions represent good steps to improve safety, aid the economy, and protect the environment. We strongly encourage Calaveras County to achieve consistency with the 2017 Draft RTP by including similar policies and implementation measures in its Circulation Element. The County must be an active partner in these endeavors if people are to reap the benefits of these particular 2017 Draft RTP policies. In addition, if the County adopted such implementation measures with sufficient commitment to achieve measurable standards, then the County could mitigate impacts of development under the Draft General Plan.
- Below is the CPC comments on the Draft 2017 RTP:
2017 RTP Letter from CPC_final
June 2017
Press Release” CPC Releases comments on Medical Cannabis Cultivation and Commerce Ordinance DEIR: Press release for Commercial Cannabis Cultivation June 2017 (1)
Planning Coalition Releases Comments on the Medical Cannabis Cultivation and Commerce Ordinance DEIR: 0 CPC – Cannabis DEIR Comments Combined in pdf
February 2017
Scoping Comments in response to the Notice of Preparation for the Calaveras County General Plan Update Environmental Impact Report:
4 Table of Contents & List of Contributors
9 Land Use and Plannind Scoping Comment
12 Traffic and Circulation scoping comments
Docume14 Guide to Attachments to assist the County in evaluating and mitigating the impacts of the General Plan Update:
AGRICULTURE:
2014_0225_marin-county-agricultural-land-conservation-program_final
Calaveras Draft Ag element October 2008
F.C. Ag preservation principles
farmlenad protection toolbox_02-2008
Monterey Agriculture Element Placer CGPPart5 Sacramento Agricultural-Element
Napa Ag Land Use Element 06-04-08
Sacramento Agricultural-Element
AIR QUALITY:
Air_Quality_-_Land_Use_handbook
BIOLOGICAL RESOURCES:
Cal_Wildlife_Action_Plan_final
GP_Bio_resources_goals_and_policies_FC
CHILD CARE FACILITIES:
including_child_care_in_local_planning
CONSERVATION AND OPEN SPACE:
Mono_ConservationOpenSpaceElement
DATA ANALYSIS:
ECONOMIC DEVELOPMENT:
InvestingforProsperity Workforce_Development_Piece_FINAL_10-08-03
Workforce_Development_Piece_FINAL_10-08-03
FIRE HAZARD PLANNING:
Fire_Hazard_Planning-Final_Report
GENERAL PLAN GUIDELINES:
DRAFT_General_Plan_Guidelines_for_public_comment_2015(2)
GLOBAL CLIMATE CHANGE:
CAPCOA_White_Paper_Climate_Change
Global_Warming_mitigation_measures
HISTORIC PRESERVATION:
LAND USE:
Calaveras Cannabis Cultivation EIS_2017
General Plan Update Community Planning Element Valley Springs Community Plan 1-26-17
PUBLIC SERVICES:
adoptedcalaveras_fire_msr_final_no_mhfpd_downsized
final_calaveras_water_wastewater_msr_2012
jbfinal_csd__csa_report_adopted_copy
TRAFFIC:
493_FinalRTP_2012CalaverasRTP_wExecAppend(2)
494_2012-Calaveras-County-RTP_PublicReviewDraft_Released-July-27-2012
BIKE TRAILS:
Amador Bike Survey Implications
Calaveras County Baseline Report Omissions
Response to Draft General Plan Baseline
WATER PLANNING:
LGC_Water_Planning_Ch_3_Sect_3_4
December 2016
8-17-16 letter to pc in pdf final8-31-16
Letter to Cal. PC re Copperopolis
October 2016
CPC Comments for BOS re. General Plan Draft & Map, BOS meeting 10/4/16:
Joyce Techel speaking on behalf of MyValleySprings.com & the Calaveras Planning Coalition:
September 2016
Calaveras Planning Coalition Position Paper – September 2016: (AN EIR IS NEEDED ON COMMERCIAL CANNABIS CULTIVATION AND ASSOCIATED ACTIVITIES)
an-eir-is-needed-on-commercial-cannabis-cpc-position
August 2015
General Plan Update:
Asphalt Plant Update:
- Letter to BOS Re Asphalt Appeal 2-8-16
- Testimony of Thomas P Infusino v2
- Valley Springs advocacy group submits asphalt plant issues to county
- Full impact of asphalt plant to be examined
- Asphalt plant fact and speculation
- CPC Letter re Asphalt Plant Appeal (00000002)
- Hot plant fact sheet misleading
June 2015
Good Planning can enhance Property Rights, Property Values & Property Interests – Presented by Tom Infusino on June 8, 2015 at CPC’s Let’s Talk About: How good planning protects property rights and how planning for economic development increases local self-sufficiency and quality of life.
Good Planning can enhance Property Rights posting
Tell the Board of Supervisors what you want in the General Plan
Last year Calaveras County released the text of the Draft General Plan for public comment. That text did not include the Community Plans. That text did not include the vision and principles developed in 2008 after two years of public workshops. The CPC drafted and distributed a petition for the Earth Day Celebration in 2015.
June 2014
Muriel Zeller – Calaveras Enterprise Columnist
Take a Lode off:
June 2014
- Items for discussion at Planning Commission on 6-12-14,
including the Saddle Creek Development Agreement Extension:
- To PC by email on Saddle Creek DA fin
- From Colleen June 26 Planning Commission:
(Ward has video posted on CAP: https://calaverascap.com/june-26-2014-calaveras-county-planning-commission/)1) At first Public Comment, I followed up on Tom’s presentation at 6/12 meeting. I thanked the commissioners for being receptive to his suggestions for mitigation and development project monitoring and establishing protocols for review of old environmental docs for extensions, and for requesting future study sessions.2) At second Public Comment, I thanked them for bringing up their desire to address the problem of residential outdoor lighting, which is not addressed in code and has come before them over and over for 5+ years, has been dealt with inconsistently, and I suggested they include language in the GPU to address and bring back in SS.3) Peter Maurer’s then made a report/ comments which are worth listening to. He seemed receptive to this idea of language in the GPU (and other ideas), and to having a study session late July or August as an annual planning project update along with addressing suggestions from Mr. Infusino. He also talked about trying to get history/background of GPU, meeting with interest groups, “working in a vacuum”, “no continuity of staff”, “bookshelves of documents” but “what’s pertinent today?” It’s worth listening to for a few minutes to get a sense of where the Director is coming from.4) Autozone filed an appeal to the BOS yesterday. They are also requesting modification of the road standards. PC Karen Sisk said “I can see problems developing there” (which I asked about afterwards and she doesn’t like the idea of a lot of access driveways and congestion in that area).
April 2014
- Written comments to DWR on the MAC IRWMP Update (April 18, 2014)
March 2014
Articles of Interest:
CAP and CPC member Bob Dean talks about Water and Land Use in an article for the Calaveras Enterprise:
- WATER AND LAND USE – Part 1
CPC member and Foothill Conservancy Executive Director Cecily Smith writes about the historic Calaveras Supervisors vote for Mokelumne River Wild & Scenic Designation:
February 2014
Presentation to public by Tom Infusion at CAP/CPC public meeting Feb. 3, 2014:
Articles of interest to CAP/CPC:
- Community plans are of utmost importance_CE-Opinon_02_07_14 (A guest opinion to the Calaveras Enterprise by CAP and CPC member Mickey Williamson
- Planners tea party find selves on common ground_SR_02_04_14
January 2014
Articles of interest to CAP/CPC:
CAP Governing Committee Co-chair and CPC member Joyce Techel letter to the Calaveras Enterprise:
Planning Updates for 2013
October 2013
Planning Updates
- Please amend the IRWMP Draft Plan Review Procedures (DPRPs)
2. Testimony of Tom Infusino, On behalf of the Calaveras Planning Coalition,
At the EBMUD Hearing in San Andreas, CA, on October 21, 2013,
Regarding the Camanche Water Permit Deadline Extension Draft EIR
September 2013
Planning Updates
- General Plan Update
August 2013
Planning Updates
- General Plan Update
- CPC’s response to the General Plan Update notice to submit policy suggestions:
- Cover for GPU Comments
- Section 1 Topics List Previously Generated
- Section 2 Integrate CEQA and Project Review
- Section 3 Earth club GPT Input
- Section 4 Community Plans
- Section 5 Policies from Optional Elements
June 2013
Planning Updates
- General Plan Update
May 2013
Planning Updates
- General Plan Update
April 2013
Planning Updates
- General Plan Update
- Letter to Calaveras Planning regarding:
- GPU Scoping before Policies
March 2013
Planning Updates
- General Plan Update
- Economic Development Workshop Comments 3-26-13 old word
- CPC General Comments on Draft Map 2: CPC General Comments on Draft MAP 2.â€
- CPC Comments on the Preliminary Setting Sections of the General Plan Update EIR.
Download Here: Draft Setting
February 2013
Planning Updates
- General Plan Update
- Re: Comments on Sawmill Project:
- Testimony of Thomas P. Infusino, Calaveras Planning Coalition: To Calaveras County Board of Supervisors, 2-26-13:Download Here: to BOS on Sawmill 2-26-13 2 final
January 2013
Planning Updates
- RE: The Calaveras Planning Coalition recommends continuing to improve the MAC IRWMP over the next two years:
- Read Tom Infusino’s letter to UMRWA Board of Directors: Letter to UMRWA on MAC IRWMP
- RE: The CPC Appreciates that the MAC IRWMP is Item 11 on the Calaveras Board of Supervisors Consent Agenda: The CPC Appreciates that the MAC IRWMP is Item 11 on the Consent Agenda
December 2012
October 2012
- Draft MAC IRWMP. (Mokelumne-Amador-Calaveras (MAC) Regional Water Management Plan Update)
September 2012
Planning Updates
- RE: Agreement with Staff Report Recommendations for the Sawmill Project on your Agenda for 9-13-12. Download here: Sawmill to P C 9-12-12 fin
April 2011 through April 2012
- 2011 TALK2 fin
- Amador GP comments June of 11.fin
- BOS email CSC
- Comments on UWMP June 6
- CPC on UWMP Final
- EBMUD Hearing 1-11-12
- EBMUD Scoping Testimony 7-14-11
- Exhaustion of Remedies (2)v fin
- Parable of the King 7-14-11
- Shooting Range Finding Add-ons_CP fin
- Testimony Before the Calaveras County Board of Supervisors on 11
- Testimony of Tom Infusino 3-13-12
Comment Letters
- In Support of Agriculture & Forestry Elements (by Muriel Zeller, 01/20/09)
- Calaveras Planning Coalition comments on Draft Water Element (01/15/09)
- Bear Valley DEIR Letter (11/04/08)
- Wallace Lake Estates Project (05/16/07)
- Crestview Estates Project (05/16/07)
- North Vista Plaza (04/28/07)
Testimony at County Hearings & Meetings
- Comments to Planning Director on Draft Economic Analysis (11/14/08)
- Comments to Board of Supervisors on Issues & Opportunity Report (08/05/08)
- Comments to Board of Supervisors on General Plan Water Element (08/05/08
- Comments to Board of Supervisors on the Extension of the Urgency Ordinance (11/23/07)
- Comments to Board of Supervisors & Planning on General Plan Update Process (04/28/07)
- Testimony on the need for Community Plan updates (08/21/07)
- Presentation at Board of Supervisors Study Session about General Plan Update by Tom Infusino (01/23/06)
- Testimony to Board of Supervisors about Blue Mountain Residential Center by Tom Infusino (10/16/06)
Op-Ed Pieces
- At the Crossroads Op-Ed by Ward La Valley
- Where Are We in the County General Plan & Community Plan Updates? A presentation to the Chamber of Commerce Panel by Tom Infusino (09/11/07)
- The Real Planning Coalition A guest opinion by Tom Infusino in response to Tom Tryon (08/31/07)
- Calaveras Needs Economic Vision Op-Ed by Steve Elias Calaveras Enterprise (11/23/07)
- The Cost of Rural Residential Development By Mickey Williamson for the Calaveras Planning Coalition(08/31/07)
- What is the Environment and Why do we Need a Report on it? By Muriel Zeller or the Calaveras Planning Coalition (05-30-07)